| Best Pitcher | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | C.C. Sabathia | 19-14 3.29 |
| Most Valuable Player | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Alex Rodriguez | .302 43 99 |
| Best Rookie Player | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Alex Rodriguez | .302 43 99 |
| Best Rookie Pitcher | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | C.C. Sabathia | 19-14 3.29 |
| Gold Glove (P) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Roger Clemens | 1.000 |
| Gold Glove (C) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| Gold Glove (1B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Travis Hafner | .993 |
| Gold Glove (2B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Robinson Cano | .977 |
| Gold Glove (3B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Casey Blake | .979 |
| Gold Glove (SS) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Derek Jeter | .987 |
| Gold Glove (LF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Hideki Matsui | .980 |
| Gold Glove (CF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Johnny Damon | .998 |
| Gold Glove (RF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Grady Sizemore | 1.000 |
| Pure Slugger (C) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Victor Martinez | .250 11 41 |
| Pure Slugger (1B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Jason Giambi | .229 31 93 |
| Pure Slugger (2B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Robinson Cano | .271 7 54 |
| Pure Slugger (3B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Alex Rodriguez | .302 43 99 |
| Pure Slugger (SS) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Jhonny Peralta | .261 17 75 |
| Pure Slugger (LF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | David Dellucci | .270 24 87 |
| Pure Slugger (CF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Johnny Damon | .275 7 42 |
| Pure Slugger (RF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 2007 League 1 | Grady Sizemore | .295 28 97 |