| A (1) | Bobby Abreu | ||||
| B (7) | Josh Barfield | Casey Blake | Wilson Betemit | Rafael Betancourt | Brian Bruney |
| C (6) | Robinson Cano | Melky Cabrera | Joba Chamberlain | Fausto Carmona | Roger Clemens |
| D (3) | Johnny Damon | David Dellucci | Shelley Duncan | ||
| E (0) | |||||
| F (2) | Kyle Farnsworth | Aaron Fultz | |||
| G (5) | Jason Giambi | Ryan Garko | Chris Gomez | Franklin Gutierrez | Alex Gonzalez |
| H (3) | Travis Hafner | Phil Hughes | Sean Henn | ||
| I (0) | |||||
| J (1) | Derek Jeter | ||||
| K (0) | |||||
| L (3) | Kenny Lofton | Cliff Lee | Jensen Lewis | ||
| M (8) | Hideki Matsui | Victor Martinez | Doug Mientkiewicz | Jason Michaels | Jose Molina |
| N (1) | Trot Nixon | ||||
| O (0) | |||||
| P (5) | Jhonny Peralta | Jorge Posada | Rafael Perez | Andy Pettitte | Andy Phillips |
| Q (0) | |||||
| R (3) | Alex Rodriguez | Luis Rivas | Mariano Rivera | ||
| S (5) | Grady Sizemore | Bronson Sardinha | Kelly Shoppach | C.C. Sabathia | Jeremy Sowers |
| T (0) | |||||
| U (0) | |||||
| V (2) | Luis Vizcaino | Ron Villone | |||
| W (2) | Chien-ming Wang | Jake Westbrook | |||
| X (0) | |||||
| Y (0) | |||||
| Z (0) | |||||